塔里木盆地寒武系超深层含油气系统盆地模拟

doi:10.7623/syxb202206005

石油学报 ›› 2022, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (6): 804-815.DOI: 10.7623/syxb202206005

塔里木盆地寒武系超深层含油气系统盆地模拟

李斌^1,2, 张欣¹, 郭强¹, 吕海涛^1,3, 杨素举³, 徐勤琪³, 彭军^1,2

1. 西南石油大学地球科学与技术学院四川成都 610500;
2. 西南石油大学油气藏地质及开发工程国家重点实验室四川成都 610500;
3. 中国石油化工股份有限公司西北油田分公司勘探开发研究院新疆乌鲁木齐 830011

收稿日期:2021-03-31 修回日期:2021-12-13 发布日期:2022-06-28
通讯作者: 李斌,男,1977年2月生,2006年获中国科学院广州地球化学研究所博士学位,现为西南石油大学副教授,主要从事油气成藏的科研和教学工作。
作者简介:李斌,男,1977年2月生,2006年获中国科学院广州地球化学研究所博士学位,现为西南石油大学副教授,主要从事油气成藏的科研和教学工作。Email:lbin@swpu.edu.cn
基金资助:
四川省区域创新合作项目"复杂油藏高效开发相关技术研究及推广应用"(2021YFQ0048)资助。第一作者及

Basin modeling of Cambrian ultra-deep petroleum system in Tarim Basin

Li Bin^1,2, Zhang Xin¹, Guo Qiang¹, Lü Haitai^1,3, Yang Suju³, Xu Qinqi³, Peng Jun^1,2

1. School of Geoscience and Technology, Southwest Petroleum University, Sichuan Chengdu 610500, China;
2. State Key Laboratory of Oil and Gas Reservoir Geology and Exploitation, Southwest Petroleum University, Sichuan Chengdu 610500, China;
3. Exploration and Production Research Institute, Sinopec Northwest Oil Field Company, Xinjiang Urumqi 830011, China

Received:2021-03-31 Revised:2021-12-13 Published:2022-06-28

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 针对塔里木盆地寒武系超深层含油气系统复杂的成藏特征,采用动力学模拟技术探讨了寒武系"源-圈-藏"的演化过程,揭示了超深层含油气系统油气"生成-运移-聚集-调整"的演化历史。塔里木盆地台盆区烃源岩的生烃史模拟显示:下寒武统烃源岩的热演化存在4个关键时刻,分别为加里东中期、加里东晚期—海西早期、海西晚期、喜马拉雅晚期;发育3种热演化模式,即盆地坳陷区持续热演化模式、盆地斜坡区接力热演化模式和盆地周缘山前带快速热演化模式。烃源岩的成熟度恢复显示:塔北斜坡带、顺托果勒低隆起和麦盖提斜坡带烃源岩的整体成熟度低于2%,处于高成熟阶段,目前仍然具有较好的生烃潜力。超深层含油气系统的混合流模拟表明:加里东期和海西期断裂对塔里木盆地原生油气藏的运聚较为重要,而喜马拉雅期断裂对次生油气藏的运聚影响较大。塔里木盆地台盆区寒武系上、下两套含油气系统流体的流线变化和运聚趋势具有明显的继承性,隆起带和斜坡区的优势运移通道是油气运聚的有利区,其中,卡塔克隆起和巴楚隆起西侧具有多源充注汇聚的特征,巴楚隆起东侧和塔北隆起受单一含油气系统持续充注,是较有利的油气富集区。盆地模拟对塔里木盆地超深层含油气系统的研究具有一定的参考价值,值得进一步探讨完善。

关键词: 含油气系统, 油气运聚, 超深层, 盆地模拟, 寒武系, 塔里木盆地

Abstract: To make clear the complex accumulation and evolution process of the Cambrian ultra-deep petroleum system in Tarim Basin, this paper explores the evolution process of Cambrian "source-trap-reservoir" by using dynamic simulation technique, and reveals the evolutionary history of "generation-migration-accumulation-adjustment" of the ultra-deep petroleum system. The simulation of the hydrocarbon generation history of source rocks in the platform-basin transitional area of Tarim Basin shows that there are four key periods in the thermal evolution of Lower Cambrian source rocks, i.e., Middle Caledonian, Late Caledonian to Early Hercynian, Late Hercynian and Late Himalayan. Three thermal evolution patterns were developed, i.e., continuous thermal evolution pattern in depression belt, continuous thermal evolution pattern in slope belt, and rapid thermal evolution pattern in piedmont belt. The maturity recovery of source rocks shows that the source rocks in Tabei slope belt, Shuntuoguole low uplift, and Maigaiti slope belt have an overall maturity of less than 2%, indicating a high maturity stage, and now still has good hydrocarbon generation potential. The simulation of mixed flow in the ultra-deep petroleum system shows that the Caledonian and Hercynian faults play an important role in the hydrocarbon accumulation and migration in primary oil-gas reservoirs in Tarim Basin, and the Himalayan faults has a great impact on the hydrocarbon migration and accumulation in secondary reservoirs. The streamline variation and accumulation trend of fluid flow in Upper and Lower Cambrian petroleum systems in platform-basin area of Tarim Basin show obvious inherited characteristics. The dominant migration pathways in uplift belts and slope belts are favorable areas for hydrocarbon migration and accumulation. Among them, the Katake uplift and the west of Bachu uplift have the characteristics of multi-source charging and accumulation; the east of Bachu uplift and the Tabei uplift were continuously charged by single petroleum system, thus being a favorable hydrocarbon accumulation area. Basin modeling has a certain reference value for the study of the ultra-deep petroleum system in Tarim Basin, which is worthy of further exploration and improvement.

Key words: petroleum system, hydrocarbon migration and accumulation, ultra-deep stratum, basin modeling, Cambrian, Tarim Basin

中图分类号:

TE121.1

李斌, 张欣, 郭强, 吕海涛, 杨素举, 徐勤琪, 彭军. 塔里木盆地寒武系超深层含油气系统盆地模拟[J]. 石油学报, 2022, 43(6): 804-815.

Li Bin, Zhang Xin, Guo Qiang, Lü Haitai, Yang Suju, Xu Qinqi, Peng Jun. Basin modeling of Cambrian ultra-deep petroleum system in Tarim Basin[J]. Acta Petrolei Sinica, 2022, 43(6): 804-815.

参考文献

[1] 田军,杨海军,朱永峰,等.塔里木盆地富满油田成藏地质条件及勘探开发关键技术[J].石油学报,2021,42(8):971-985.
TIAN Jun,YANG Haijun,ZHU Yongfeng,et al.Geological conditions for hydrocarbon accumulation and key technologies for exploration and development in Fuman oilfield,Tarim Basin[J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,2021,42(8):971-985.
[2] 闫磊,朱光有,王珊,等.塔里木盆地震旦系-寒武系万米超深层天然气成藏条件与有利区带优选[J].石油学报,2021,42(11):1446-1457.
YAN Lei,ZHU Guangyou,WANG Shan,et al.Accmulation conditions and favorable areas for natural gas accumulation in the 10000 meters ultra-deep Sinian-Cambrian in Tarim Basin[J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,2021,42(11):1446-1457.
[3] DING Zhiwen,WANG Rujun,CHEN Fangfang,et al.Origin,hydrocarbon accumulation and oil-gas enrichment of fault-karst carbonate reservoirs:a case study of Ordovician carbonate reservoirs in South Tahe area of Halahatang oilfield,Tarim Basin[J].Petroleum Exploration and Development,2020,47(2):306-317.
[4] 焦方正.塔里木盆地顺托果勒地区北东向走滑断裂带的油气勘探意义[J].石油与天然气地质,2017,38(5):831-839.
JIAO Fangzheng.Significance of oil and gas exploration in NE strike-slip fault belts in Shuntuoguole area of Tarim Basin[J].Oil&Gas Geology,2017,38(5):831-839.
[5] 顾忆,万旸璐,黄继文,等."大埋深、高压力"条件下塔里木盆地超深层油气勘探前景[J].石油实验地质,2019,41(2):157-164.
GU Yi,WAN Yanglu,HUANG Jiwen,et al.Prospects for ultra-deep oil and gas in the"deep burial and high pressure"Tarim Basin[J].Petroleum Geology&Experiment,2019,41(2):157-164.
[6] EL GAWAD E A A,GHANEM M F,LOTFY M M.Burial and thermal history simulation of the subsurface Paleozoic source rocks in Faghur Basin,Northwestern Desert,Egypt:implication for hydrocarbon generation and expulsion history[J].Egyptian Journal of Petroleum,2019,28(3):261-271.
[7] PIÑERO E,HENSEN C,HAECKEL M,et al.3-D numerical modelling of methane hydrate accumulations using PetroMod[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2016,71:288-295.
[8] MAKEEN Y M,ABDULLAH W H,PEARSON M J,et al.History of hydrocarbon generation,migration and accumulation in the Fula sub-basin,Muglad Basin,Sudan:implications of a 2D basin modeling study[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2016,77:931-941.
[9] CHEN Jiaxu,GUO Xiaowen,HAN Yuanjia,et al.Combination of basin modelling and carbazoles to investigate secondary oil migration pathways in the Dongying depression of the Bohai Bay Basin,China[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2021,131:105163.
[10] 冯兴强,宋海明.塔河油田碎屑岩油气运聚模拟及潜力区优选[J].地质力学学报,2020,26(6):892-900.
FENG Xingqiang,SONG Haiming.Simulation of oil-gas accumulation of clastic rocks and potential areas in the Tahe oilfield[J].Journal of Geomechanics,2020,26(6):892-900.
[11] 郭秋麟,陈宁生,柳庄小雪,等.盆地模拟关键技术之油气运聚模拟技术进展[J].石油实验地质,2020,42(5):846-857.
GUO Qiulin,CHEN Ningsheng,LIU Zhuangxiaoxue,et al.Advance of basin modeling key techniques:hydrocarbon migration and accumulation simulation[J].Petroleum Geology&Experiment,2020,42(5):846-857.
[12] 徐长贵,彭靖淞,吴庆勋,等.渤海湾凹陷区复杂断裂带垂向优势运移通道及油气运移模拟[J].石油勘探与开发,2019,46(4):684-692.
XU Changgui,PENG Jingsong,WU Qingxun,et al.Vertical dominant migration channel and hydrocarbon migration in complex fault zone,Bohai Bay sag,China[J].Petroleum Exploration and Development,2019,46(4):684-692.
[13] 杨海军,陈永权,田军,等.塔里木盆地轮探1井超深层油气勘探重大发现与意义[J].中国石油勘探,2020,25(2):62-72.
YANG Haijun,CHEN Yongquan,TIAN Jun,et al.An important discovery in Well Luntan-1 of the Tarim Basin,China,and its significance for ultra-deep oil and gas exploration[J].China Petroleum Exploration,2020,25(2):62-72.
[14] 朱光有,陈斐然,陈志勇,等.塔里木盆地寒武系玉尔吐斯组优质烃源岩的发现及其基本特征[J].天然气地球科学,2016,27(1):8-21.
ZHU Guangyou,CHEN Feiran,CHEN Zhiyong,et al.Discovery and basic characteristics of the high-quality source rocks of the Cambrian Yuertusi Formation in Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Geoscience,2016,27(1):8-21.
[15] 李峰,朱光有,吕修祥,等.塔里木盆地古生界海相油气来源争议与寒武系主力烃源岩的确定[J].石油学报,2021,42(11):1417-1436.
LI Feng,ZHU Guangyou,LV Xiuxiang,et al.The disputes on the source of Paleozoic marine oil and gas and the determination of the Cambrian system as the main source rocks in Tarim Basin[J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,2021,42(11):1417-1436.
[16] 张春宇,管树巍,吴林,等.塔西北地区早寒武世玉尔吐斯组热液作用及沉积模式[J].地学前缘,2019,26(1):202-211.
ZHANG Chunyu,GUAN Shuwei,WU Lin,et al.Hydrothermal activity and depositional model of the Yurtus Formation in the Early Cambrian,NW Tarim,China[J].Earth Science Frontiers,2019,26(1):202-211.
[17] 吴鲜,李丹,韩俊,等.塔里木盆地顺托果勒北部地区超深层现今地温场特征[J].石油学报,2022,43(1):29-40.
WU Xian,LI Dan,HAN Jun,et al.Characteristics of present ultra-deep geothermal field in the northern Shuntuoguole low uplift,Tarim Basin[J].Acta Petrolei Sinica,2022,43(1):29-40.
[18] 任战利,田涛,李进步,等.沉积盆地热演史研究方法与叠合盆地热演化史恢复研究进展[J].地球科学与环境学报,2014,36(3):1-21.
REN Zhanli,TIAN Tao,LI Jinbu,et al.Review on methods of thermal evolution history in sedimentary basins and thermal evolution history reconstruction of superimposed basins[J].Journal of Earth Sciences and Environment,2014,36(3):1-21.
[19] ZHU Guangyou,CAO Yinghui,YAN Lei,et al.Potential and favorable areas of petroleum exploration of ultra-deep marine strata more than 8000m deep in the Tarim Basin,Northwest China[J].Journal of Natural Gas Geoscience,2018,3(6):321-337.
[20] 中国石油化工股份有限公司西北油田分公司.塔里木盆地主要烃源岩演化及油气资源评价[R].中国石油化工股份有限公司西北油田分公司,2014.
Sinopec Northwest Oilfield Company.Evolution of main source rocks and evaluation of petroleum resources in Tarim Basin[R].Sinopec Northwest Oilfield Company,2014.
[21] HADAD Y T,HAKIMI M H,ABDULLAH W H,et al.Basin modeling of the Late Miocene Zeit source rock in the Sudanese portion of Red Sea Basin:implication for hydrocarbon generation and expulsion history[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2017,84:311-322.
[22] 郑见超,李斌,刘羿伶,等.塔里木盆地下寒武统玉尔吐斯组烃源岩热演化模拟分析[J].油气藏评价与开发,2018,8(6):7-12.
ZHENG Jianchao,LI Bin,LIU Yiling,et al.Study on thermal evolution modeling of Lower Cambrian Yuertusi source rock,Tarim Basin[J].Reservoir Evaluation and Development,2018,8(6):7-12.
[23] 郑见超,李斌,吴海燕,等.基于盆地模拟技术的烃源岩热演化史及油气关系研究——以塔里木盆地玉尔吐斯组为例[J].油气地质与采收率,2018,25(5):39-49.
ZHENG Jianchao,LI Bin,WU Haiyan,et al.Study on the thermal history of the source rock and its relationshipwith hydrocarbon accumulation based on the basin modeling technology:a case of the Yuertusi Formation of Tarim Basin[J].Petroleum Geology and Recovery Efficiency,2018,25(5):39-49.
[24] 张光亚,赵文智,王红军,等.塔里木盆地多旋回构造演化与复合含油气系统[J].石油与天然气地质,2007,28(5):653-663.
ZHANG Guangya,ZHAO Wenzhi,WANG Hongjun,et al.Multicycle tectonic evolution and composite petroleum systems in the Tarim Basin[J].Oil&Gas Geology,2007,28(5):653-663.
[25] 胡杰,龙祖烈,黄玉平,等.珠江口盆地白云凹陷新生代构造-热演化模拟[J].地球物理学报,2021,64(5):1654-1665.
HU Jie,LONG Zulie,HUANG Yuping,et al.Tectono-thermal modelling of Baiyun sag,Pearl River Mouth Basin,since Cenozoic[J].Chinese Journal of Geophysics,2021,64(5):1654-1665.
[26] 邓宾,何宇,黄家强,等.前陆盆地形成与演化砂箱物理模拟启示——以四川盆地西部龙门山为例[J].石油与天然气地质,2021,42(2):401-415.
DENG Bin,HE Yu,HUANG Jiaqiang,et al.Analogue modeling insights to foreland basin growth:a case study on the Longmenshan thrust belt in western Sichuan Basin[J].Oil&Gas Geology,2021,42(2):401-415.
[27] JIU Bo,HUANG Wenhui,MU Nana,et al.Effect of hydrothermal fluids on the ultra-deep Ordovician carbonate rocks in Tarim Basin,China[J].Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2020,194:107445.
[28] JIANG Tongwen,TENG Xueqing,YANG Xiangtong.Integrated techniques for rapid and highly-efficient development and production of ultra-deep tight sand gas reservoirs of Keshen 8 block in the Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Industry B,2017,4(1):30-38.
[29] JIANG Tongwen,SUN Xiongwei.Development of Keshen ultra-deep and ultra-high pressure gas reservoirs in the Kuqa foreland basin,Tarim Basin:understanding and technical countermeasures[J].Natural Gas Industry B,2019,6(1):16-24.
[30] 陈斐然,张义杰,朱光有,等.塔里木盆地台盆区深层天然气地球化学特征及成藏演化[J].天然气地球科学,2018,29(6):880-891.
CHEN Feiran,ZHANG Yijie,ZHU Guangyou,et al.Geochemistry and accumulation process of deep natural gas in the platform-basin region, Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Geoscience,2018,29(6):880-891.
[31] LIU Jianliang,JIANG Zhenxue,LIU Keyu,et al.Hydrocarbon sources and charge history in the southern slope region,Kuqa foreland basin,northwestern China[J].Marine and Petroleum Geology,2016,74:26-46.
[32] 倪斌,汤良杰,李萌,等.塔里木盆地鸟山东断裂带构造特征、形成机制及油气地质意义[J].天然气地球科学,2018,29(6):834-844.
NI Bin,TANG Liangjie,LI Meng,et al.Structural characteristics,formation mechanism and petroleum geological significances of east Niaoshan fault zone,Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Geoscience,2018,29(6):834-844.
[33] 范青青,卢双舫,李文浩,等.中下寒武统海相地层地球化学特征及油气地质意义——以塔里木盆地柯坪地区为例[J].中国矿业大学学报,2019,48(2):377-394.
FAN Qingqing,LU Shuangfang,LI Wenhao,et al.Geochemical characteristics and geological significance for petroleum of the Middle-Lower Cambrian marine strata:a case study of Keping area in the Tarim Basin[J].Journal of China University of Mining&Technology,2019,48(2):377-394.
[34] 米石云.盆地模拟技术研究现状及发展方向[J].中国石油勘探,2009,14(2):55-58.
MI Shiyun.Basin modeling technology development situation and its main trends[J].China Petroleum Exploration,2009,14(2):55-58.
[35] 王道伟,王铁冠,李美俊,等.塔中隆起中深5井与中深1井和烷基分布特征与油源启示[J].地球化学,2016,45(5):451-461.
WANG Daowei,WANG Tieguan,LI Meijun,et al.The distribution of chrysene and methylchrysenes in oils from wells ZS5 and ZS1 in the Tazhong uplift and its implications in oil-to-source correlation[J].Geochimica,2016,45(5):451-461.
[36] 宋到福,王铁冠,李美俊.塔中地区中深1和中深1C井盐下寒武系油气地球化学特征及其油气源判识[J].中国科学:地球科学,2016,46(1):107-117.
SONG Daofu,WANG Tieguan,LI Meijun.Geochemistry and possible origin of the hydrocarbons from wells Zhongshen1 and Zhongshen1C,Tazhong uplift[J].Science China Earth Sciences,2016,59(4):840-850.
[37] 王艳星.塔里木油田亚洲陆上第一深井获工业油气流[J].炼油技术与工程,2020,50(3):64.
WANG Yanxing.Industrial oil flow from Asia's first deep well in Tarim oilfield[J].Petroleum Refinery Engineering,2020,50(3):64.
[38] 胡明毅,孙春燕,高达.塔里木盆地下寒武统肖尔布拉克组构造-岩相古地理特征[J].石油与天然气地质,2019,40(1):12-23.
HU Mingyi,SUN Chunyan,GAO Da.Characteristics of tectonic-lithofacies paleogeography in the Lower Cambrian Xiaoerbulake Formation,Tarim Basin[J].Oil&Gas Geology,2019,40(1):12-23.
[39] 张海坤,周世新,付德亮,等.塔里木盆地塔深1井深层油气相态预测[J].天然气地球科学,2013,24(5):999-1004.
ZHANG Haikun,ZHOU Shixin,FU Deliang,et al.Petroleum phase state prediction in deep reservoir of Tashen-1 Well in Tarim Basin[J].Natural Gas Geoscience,2013,24(5):999-1004.

塔里木盆地寒武系超深层含油气系统盆地模拟

Basin modeling of Cambrian ultra-deep petroleum system in Tarim Basin

PDF

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 15

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价

[1]	黄亚浩, 汪如军, 文志刚, 张银涛, 崔仕提, 李梦勤, 王彭, 何涛华. 塔里木盆地富满油田深层—超深层油气成藏过程[J]. 石油学报, 2024, 45(6): 947-960.
[2]	王清华, 徐振平, 张荣虎, 杨海军, 杨宪彰. 塔里木盆地油气勘探新领域、新类型及资源潜力[J]. 石油学报, 2024, 45(1): 15-32.
[3]	宋永, 唐勇, 何文军, 龚德瑜, 晏奇, 陈棡, 单祥, 刘超威, 刘刚, 秦志军, 阿布力米提·依明, 尤新才, 任海姣, 白雨, 高岗. 准噶尔盆地油气勘探新领域、新类型及勘探潜力[J]. 石油学报, 2024, 45(1): 52-68.
[4]	赵金洲, 雍锐, 胡东风, 佘朝毅, 付永强, 吴建发, 蒋廷学, 任岚, 周博, 林然. 中国深层—超深层页岩气压裂:问题、挑战与发展方向[J]. 石油学报, 2024, 45(1): 295-311.
[5]	刘岩生, 张佳伟, 黄洪春. 中国深层—超深层钻完井关键技术及发展方向[J]. 石油学报, 2024, 45(1): 312-324.
[6]	贾承造, 庞雄奇, 郭秋麟, 陈掌星, 王飞宇, 刘国勇, 高永进, 施砍园, 姜福杰, 姜林. 基于成因法评价油气资源:全油气系统理论和新一代盆地模拟技术[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(9): 1399-1416.
[7]	庞雄奇, 贾承造, 郭秋麟, 陈掌星, 王飞宇, 刘国勇, 高永进, 施砍园, 姜福杰, 姜林. 全油气系统理论用于常规和非常规油气资源评价的盆地模拟技术原理及应用[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(9): 1417-1433.
[8]	刘可禹, 刘建良. 盆地沉积充填演化与含油气系统耦合模拟方法在超深层油气成藏模拟中的应用——以四川盆地中部震旦系灯影组为例[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(9): 1445-1458.
[9]	郭秋麟, 黄少英, 卢玉红, 王建, 吴晓智, 陈宁生. 塔里木盆地台盆区下古生界油气系统模拟及资源分布预测[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(9): 1459-1471.
[10]	宋振响, 周卓明, 江兴歌, 陈拥锋, 马中良, 罗昕, 李振明. 常规-非常规油气资源一体化评价方法——基于全油气系统理论和TSM盆地模拟技术[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(9): 1487-1499.
[11]	贾承造, 张荣虎, 魏国齐, 王珂, 余朝丰, 曾庆鲁, 司学强. 天山陆内冲断带构造动力控储效应与超深层规模储层[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(8): 1191-1205.
[12]	鹿腾, 李兆敏, 顾子涵, 穆金峰, 丁国, 王一平, 杜华君. 超深层稠油降黏泡沫体系微观作用机理及其矿场应用[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(8): 1344-1355.
[13]	陈利新, 贾承造, 姜振学, 苏洲, 杨美纯, 杨博, 邱晨. 塔里木盆地哈拉哈塘地区碳酸盐岩富油模式与主控因素[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(6): 948-961.
[14]	孔悦, 高晓鹏, 石开波, 刘波, 姜伟民, 于进鑫, 何卿, 吴淳. 塔北地区奥陶系鹰山组斑状白云岩成因及储层意义[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(4): 598-611.
[15]	赖锦, 肖露, 赵鑫, 赵飞, 黎雨航, 朱世发, 王贵文, 刘宏坤. 深层—超深层优质碎屑岩储层成因与测井评价方法——以库车坳陷白垩系巴什基奇克组为例[J]. 石油学报, 2023, 44(4): 612-625.